This week Jonathan Dunn sails towards the end of his time with Paper Mario: The 'Orange Army' King lumping high praise on Mario's latest papery adventure. Minty Booth swings back towards loving rather than loathing the same title, allowing it to leap frog the inconsistent Colour Splash in his hypothetically revised list. Christopher Dow nears the end of Alice: Madness Returns, and revisits Deadly Premonition for some Lynchian spooks.
Want to know our 28th favourite games of all time?
Minty gardens his way to sweet victory in Viva Piñata, Rare's gorgeous 360-era animal management simulation.
Chris feels embarrassed discussing his relatively miniscule time with the smorgasbord of content and riches that is The Binding of Isaac when viewed against Jonathan and Minty's playtime and mastery.
Jonathan finds a magic coin and wishes the sumptuous Rayman into his childhood possession.
Top banana.